7,157
edits
Chirality: Difference between revisions
→2026
(→2025) |
(→2026) |
||
| Line 1,873: | Line 1,873: | ||
|usernameurl=https://x.com/EricRWeinstein | |usernameurl=https://x.com/EricRWeinstein | ||
|username=EricRWeinstein | |username=EricRWeinstein | ||
|content=@grok @nu_phases @skdh Sorry. Witten and Susskind and Gross and Motl and Kaku etc. etc. are COLLEGIAL???!? | |content=@grok @nu_phases @skdh Sorry. [[Ed Witten|Witten]] and [[Lenny Susskind|Susskind]] and [[David Gross|Gross]] and Motl and [[Michio Kaku|Kaku]] etc. etc. are COLLEGIAL???!? | ||
I’m all ears @grok. | I’m all ears @grok. | ||
| Line 1,890: | Line 1,890: | ||
Sorry, @grok. Disappointed. Good to know that humans still have one advantage over the machine: we can think original thoughts supported by data. | Sorry, @grok. Disappointed. Good to know that humans still have one advantage over the machine: we can think original thoughts supported by data. | ||
Witten is not a collegial scientist. | [[Ed Witten|Witten]] is not a collegial scientist.</br> | ||
Nor is Susskind. | Nor is [[Lenny Susskind|Susskind]].</br> | ||
Nor is Kaku. | Nor is [[Michio Kaku|Kaku]].</br> | ||
Nor is Motl. | Nor is Motl.</br> | ||
Etc | Etc | ||
| Line 1,905: | Line 1,905: | ||
|usernameurl=https://x.com/EricRWeinstein | |usernameurl=https://x.com/EricRWeinstein | ||
|username=EricRWeinstein | |username=EricRWeinstein | ||
|content=@grok @nu_phases @skdh Here. You can hear me playing Ed Witten offering up this piece of anti-scientific nonsense on Chris Williamson’s podcast. | |content=@grok @nu_phases @skdh Here. You can hear me playing [[Ed Witten]] offering up this piece of anti-scientific nonsense on Chris Williamson’s podcast. | ||
This is not colleagial behavior in an elder, a leader or an arbiter of what is and is not physics or even science. https://t.co/DyaE72GlEN | This is not colleagial behavior in an elder, a leader or an arbiter of what is and is not physics or even science. https://t.co/DyaE72GlEN | ||
| Line 1,916: | Line 1,916: | ||
|usernameurl=https://x.com/EricRWeinstein | |usernameurl=https://x.com/EricRWeinstein | ||
|username=EricRWeinstein | |username=EricRWeinstein | ||
|content=I’d prioritize owning up to the TOGIT anti-science cult needing to being purged. | |content=I’d prioritize owning up to the [[The Only Game in Town (TOGIT)|TOGIT]] anti-science cult needing to being purged. | ||
Failure happens in science. We can’t lose physics because we dare not confront or disturb those who have never played by the rules of science in their entire careers. | Failure happens in science. We can’t lose physics because we dare not confront or disturb those who have never played by the rules of science in their entire careers. | ||
| Line 1,952: | Line 1,952: | ||
|content=@nu_phases @skdh @grok Many things have happened in general physics in 50 years: | |content=@nu_phases @skdh @grok Many things have happened in general physics in 50 years: | ||
Experimental | Experimental</br> | ||
Mathematical | Mathematical</br> | ||
Topological | Topological</br> | ||
Condensed Matter | Condensed Matter</br> | ||
Astrophysical | Astrophysical</br> | ||
Cosmological | Cosmological</br> | ||
QFT as a toolkit framework | QFT as a toolkit framework</br> | ||
Etc. | Etc. | ||
That’s not what we are discussing, is it? | That’s not what we are discussing, is it? | ||
We are discussing the SM plus GR Lagrangians no? | We are discussing the [[Standard Model|SM]] plus [[General Relativity|GR]] Lagrangians no? | ||
|timestamp=8:27 PM · Jan 03, 2026 | |timestamp=8:27 PM · Jan 03, 2026 | ||
}} | }} | ||
| Line 1,980: | Line 1,980: | ||
The problem isn’t any of this. | The problem isn’t any of this. | ||
The problem is only one group is allowed to present ideas about the origins of the SM and GR without derision, deliberate misinterpretation, theft, character assassination, inteuendo. This is “The Only Game In Town” or TOGIT cult. Some of us have tried to challenge this group scientifically for more than 40 years. | The problem is only one group is allowed to present ideas about the origins of the SM and GR without derision, deliberate misinterpretation, theft, character assassination, inteuendo. This is [[The Only Game in Town (TOGIT)|“The Only Game In Town” or TOGIT]] cult. Some of us have tried to challenge this group scientifically for more than 40 years. | ||
The trouble is when you say “Let’s hear from all the people with ideas that directly *contradict* the String Theory leaders.” | The trouble is when you say “Let’s hear from all the people with ideas that directly *contradict* the String Theory leaders.” | ||
| Line 1,988: | Line 1,988: | ||
And everyone who dares to say this is scapegoated. | And everyone who dares to say this is scapegoated. | ||
The QG leaders all failed us Daniel. They will never break the logjam that they created and cannot acknowledge. | The [[Quantum Gravity|QG]] leaders all failed us Daniel. They will never break the logjam that they created and cannot acknowledge. | ||
Their critics would. But they cannot get close as they are STILL not allowed to question the failed program as members in good standing inside the system. | Their critics would. But they cannot get close as they are STILL not allowed to question the failed program as members in good standing inside the system. | ||
| Line 2,005: | Line 2,005: | ||
|content=@nu_phases @skdh @grok Something is not right in your picture: | |content=@nu_phases @skdh @grok Something is not right in your picture: | ||
“But part of the problem is your reframing QG = all fundamental physics.” | “But part of the problem is your reframing [[Quantum Gravity|QG]] = all fundamental physics.” | ||
I’m saying the opposite. I’m saying that the QG people made all of fundamental physics about their view of quantizing gravity. I’m saying that was the catastrophe. | I’m saying the opposite. I’m saying that the [[Quantum Gravity|QG]] people made all of fundamental physics about their view of quantizing gravity. I’m saying that was the catastrophe. | ||
|timestamp=10:19 PM · Jan 03, 2026 | |timestamp=10:19 PM · Jan 03, 2026 | ||
}} | }} | ||
| Line 2,020: | Line 2,020: | ||
No one smart wants to complain. They want to do work, have it evaluated and get credit for their ideas so they can do more work and have a good life. | No one smart wants to complain. They want to do work, have it evaluated and get credit for their ideas so they can do more work and have a good life. | ||
The complainers are those trying to say “No one gets to give seminars about the origin of chirality or 3 generations unless it comes out of The Only Game In Town: | The complainers are those trying to say “No one gets to give seminars about the origin of chirality or 3 generations unless it comes out of [[The Only Game in Town (TOGIT)|The Only Game In Town]]: | ||
|timestamp=10:22 PM · Jan 03, 2026 | |timestamp=10:22 PM · Jan 03, 2026 | ||
}} | }} | ||
| Line 2,150: | Line 2,150: | ||
These models have 3 features: | These models have 3 features: | ||
A) Symmetic Laws | A) Symmetic Laws</br> | ||
B) Symmetric Boundary Conditions | B) Symmetric Boundary Conditions</br> | ||
C) Emergent Chiral Decoupling | C) Emergent Chiral Decoupling | ||